If you’ve been following Dr. Ekman’s work, you’ll know there is no single, definitive sign that we can count on to let us know with absolute certainty that someone is lying. Instead, deception detection is a more complex and nuanced process, gathering possible clues to deceit, and investigating further. This often involves observing one’s behavior to establish a “baseline”, and collecting information about any deviation from this norm, in the form of “hot spots”.
When observing someone, body language is one of five channels of information to pay attention to, along with facial expressions, voice, verbal style and verbal content. There are many pseudoscience claims and myths about how to tell if someone is lying based on their body language. Here, we will distinguish what science tells us about nonverbal communication and deception.
Dr. Ekman studied three types of gestures : illustrators, manipulators and emblems.
Of these three types of gestures, there are many myths about manipulators in particular. However, the only type of gesture that can reliably provide clues to deception are emblems.
Lie catchers often mistakenly judge a truthful person to be lying because they show many manipulators. An increase in manipulator activity is not a reliable sign of deceit, but many people think it is. People observing manipulators are subject to the two biggest errors in detecting lies: the Brokaw Hazard (failing to account for individual differences in behavior) and the Othello Error (failing to understand that emotions don’t tell you their cause).
Accounting for the Brokaw Hazard, there is a great deal of individual difference in the type and frequency of manipulators a person shows. So, simply observing someone to be using “a lot” of manipulators does not in itself reveal anything about that person’s emotional state or whether they may be lying. For some people, using many manipulators is a part of their baseline behavior.
Considering the Othello Error, while it is true that manipulators often increase when someone is feeling discomfort, you can not know simply by observing their behavior (an increase in manipulators), what the cause of that discomfort could be. There could be many possible reasons for feeling uncomfortable, apart from lying.
Furthermore, manipulators are unreliable as signs of deceit because they may indicate opposite states- discomfort or relaxation. In addition to increasing in a state of discomfort, manipulators may also increase when someone is very at ease and “letting their hair down”.
Also, considering that an increase in manipulators has entered the general folklore as something that betrays deceit, a motivated liar will likely be aware of this and consciously inhibit their manipulators.
Sometimes, when people believe they cannot or should not reveal something that they are thinking, emblematic slips occur, revealing information the person wants to conceal. Often the person who shows the emblematic slip is unaware of doing so. In emblematic slips, only a fragment of the full emblem may be shown. Often it is outside of the presentation position, the space right in front of the person’s chest or face.
Dr. Ekman has studied three common examples of emblematic slips:
Along with micro expressions, emblematic slips have proven to be some of the most valuable body language signals that a person is lying. However, remember that this form of nonverbal communication does not always occur during deception. As with other signs of lying we have discovered, its absence means nothing, though its presence can be revealing.
To empower yourself to detect lies, you can learn more about nonverbal communication, the science of deception, and train to detect micro expressions.
What is the relationship between stress and emotion? In some ways, stress and emotions are…
What to do when your child lies What are we to do when we…
The three part process of emotional triggers How are emotions triggered? When an emotion is…
Eve Ekman brings you a brief talk on empathetic joy, gratitude, and genuine happiness.…
Understanding our appraisal process Eve Ekman brings you a brief talk on emotions and stress.…
The benefits of counting your blessings When it comes to cultivating gratitude, many of us…
This website uses cookies.